Not since the summer of 1666, as young Zack Newton sat pondering gravity, has so much attention been paid to a falling apple.
Should we care about AAPL’s deteriorating powers of levitation? The $200/share drop since its September highs, especially on the heels of a new dividend and share buyback program, has been unnerving. But, if you invest based on fundamentals, it’s a solid company selling at 11 times earnings and a 62% 5-year CAGR — which happens to be on sale.
If you pay attention to chart patterns, however, AAPL is flirting with disaster. It’s a mere point or two from completing a Head & Shoulders pattern that targets the low 300’s. [To read about how H&S patterns work, click HERE.]
Even if you don’t give a darn about chart patterns, know that many other investors do. The four tags of the white trend line (the neckline) in the past month are ample proof. So are the many previously completed patterns that weighed on AAPL.
In January 2008, AAPL completed a H&S pattern that saw share prices drop from 200 to 115 in a few short weeks.
Buyers at 115 were rewarded with a rebound to 190, then punished by a plunge to 78 as the rebound completed a right shoulder in a much larger H&S pattern.
Not every pattern plays out, of course. Consider the pattern below — a well-formed pattern that targeted much lower prices.
Instead of a big drop off, AAPL found channel support before much damage was done. Prices rebounded to new highs where they formed a new pattern (in white) which did play out.
Like any other chart pattern, H&S patterns don’t occur in a vacuum. Channels and harmonics often influence the ultimate outcome.
The channel that saved the day in 1995 is still with us, though it most recently offered resistance to higher prices instead of a floor. It’s the white channel in the chart below.
The much smaller, steeply rising purple channel, on the other hand, has kept prices rising — putting AAPL back on track after two significant sell-offs. It’s currently around 445 — within a few points of the Crab Pattern 1.618 extension of the failed mid-November rally.
If the current H&S pattern plays out and AAPL drops below the purple channel support, there’s another, less bullish channel that could come into play — seen in yellow below.
The next lower channel line is in the vicinity of the purple line referenced above: 430 or so. But, if gravity takes hold, mid-line support doesn’t show up until around 300. Ouch.
There are a dozen or more other patterns that could easily influence AAPL’s future (consider, for instance, the grey channel I’ve sketched in — the mid-line of which marked this morning’s lows.) There are also many fundamental events that could strengthen the price.
The company’s current share buyback scheme, for instance, is only $10 billion — about the average daily volume at $500/share. But, with $120 billion in cash on the books and virtually no debt, the company could easily expand it to a more meaningful level.
If this most widely held stock were to crash, could the rest of the market be far behind? I think there’s little question it would. Such an outcome would spell disaster for the bullish story line that TPTB have been working so diligently to construct.
Might they join company insiders in supporting the stock here at 500? It would be a lot cheaper than another round of QE and, in the end, probably more effective.
Stay tuned.
UPDATE: 1:00 PM
This morning, AAPL reached the downside targets we identified back on November 27 [see: Update on AAPL: Nov 27, 2012.] My thoughts at the time were that AAPL (then at 590) was about to reverse and retreat to the 500 area where we were likely to get a bounce before breaking down to 472-493, with 486 being the sweet spot.
Here’s the chart I posted back then, showing 486 as the (Crab Pattern) 1.618 extension of the 570 – 705 rally between July and September.
AAPL did, in fact, reverse at 594 a few sessions later — forming a now-obvious right shoulder. It bounced not once but twice at 500ish before completing the Crab Pattern this morning.
The chart below shows the actual price moves overlaid on that Nov 27 forecast.
With this morning’s plunge, AAPL also tagged the .618 of the 354 – 705 rally (from the Oct 4, 2011 low) and the 1.272 of the small Butterfly pattern discussed above. The fact that it did so without a comparable sell-off in the general markets is potentially significant.
I certainly won’t discount the possibility of a bounce off the 1.272. But, a close below 500 does significant damage to the upside case.
continued for members…
My supposition back in November was that this dip in AAPL would correlate with a broad-based correction. Since SPX has only shed 9 points (at this morning’s low) from last Friday’s high, a sizable bounce in AAPL could be bullish for SPX.
Most H&S patterns back-test their broken necklines. If AAPL back tests to 501 and continues down, SPX should follow. If, however, AAPL blows through 501, it increases the odds of new highs for SPX.
The white grid that provides the .618 at 488.26 should be significant. It begins at the Oct 4 2011 low (also SPX’s 2011 low) at which point AAPL had lost about 18%, and runs to the 705 high. The major turn at the .500 on the way up to 705 provided a Point X for the just completed Crab Pattern.
If AAPL pushes below the 488 level, however, the next major Fib support would be at the .786 of 429 — also the scene of APPL’s 2011 high. I doubt the markets could ignore another $50 billion in lost market value.
UPDATE: 3:20 PM
One last AAPL chart: the daily RSI. If AAPL closes near its lows on the day, additional downside looks very likely. It’s lost support from the yellow mid-line and is currently holding on to the white 25% line as the market goes slightly green on the day.
The purple channel is a bit speculative, but seems like a good fit. Needless to say, a drop to the bottom of it would entail more losses for AAPL, especially if there’s a little bounce (back test the yellow mid-line?) and a purple tag on positive divergence.
It’s hard to know what price level that would entail, but suffice it to say it would be 472 or lower — maybe much lower. The larger, more established channels are the white and yellow, and each of them allows for much lower prices with a channel bottom tag.
Much of it comes down to the overall market’s trajectory. SPX’s daily RSI turned down within the channel we constructed a couple of weeks ago. But, obviously, the market has yet to show much enthusiasm for a correction.
As long as RSI hangs up there near the top of the yellow channel, I have to consider the very real possibility of a break out rather than break down.
The 60-min chart looks a little more promising for bears, with an apparent rising wedge back test on negative divergence (just like the daily chart) — all in the vicinity of the .886 Fib retracement (of 1576 – 666) that started things heading south last September.
SPX is forming a broadening, descending triangle at the moment. And, these can break in either direction.
It’s hard to imagine the market will continue to do nothing all the way through until the debt ceiling/fiscal cliff wheels come off the bus. So, I’ll sit short, waiting for a move in one direction or the other to show the way.
Meanwhile, the euro continues to look overbought and the dollar oversold. Check out the 4hr charts, which look very ripe for a rollover.
Stay tuned.









Comments
8 responses to “AAPL: Flirting with Disaster”
Is it just me, or does it feel like this market will never drop? Bulls are simply invincible with the FED backing them up….PW, curious to know your thought on EW, they are calling for a triangle in USD, target 80.5 for the final E wave, then plunge below 79. What do you think?
Hello PW, by now, we all know that stocks are not allowed to drop in year 2013. The past 2 weeks are unreal. I am curious to know if SPX indeed makes a new high, how would it affect your investment plan? Can I assume this.. even if SPX exceeds 1474 for a while, it would still fall back to 1350 or lower sometimes this year. I am just guessing.
Depends on how and by how much it exceeds 1474 (if it does), strength/breadth, which Fib levels, etc.
Never is a long, long time. But, it is getting a bit monotonous. 11 sessions in a row averaging 8.64 daily range, much like Mar 2011.
USD 1474, so I’m taking a wait and see approach. Not sure which “they” you refer to when mentioning “EW.” If it’s EWI, I gave up on them long ago.
http://www.cxoadvisory.com/3525/individual-gurus/robert-prechter/
When I said “they” for EW guys, I am referring to Pretzel Logic, not sure if you have read his stuff, but he seems to know what he is doing, AR hangs around that forum alot too. As you might or might not know, Wavers are calling for higher than 1474..just a thought..but look at aapl today, down 3% yesterday, today up 3% as if nothing have happened, all dips are being bought. It does give you the feeling that the market is not allowed to drop…
“It would be a lot cheaper than another round of QE and, in the end, probably more effective.”
Awesome — made my day for sure.
I suppose I should keep my trap shut. Don’t want to give them any more bad ideas…
Hehehe … at this point though, I agree with you: to 1474.51 or not to 1474.51, that is the question. I feel that Apple has been deliberately allowed to fall, and like you say, a magical earnings release (is it next week) will be the catalyst that this market is looking for at this point.