pebblewriter

Tag: butterfly

  • Two Targets Down…

    Yesterday, we hit our initial downside target laid out over the weekend [see: So Far, So Good] when we nailed the Fibonacci .886 retracement of the Butterfly pattern (purple) we’ve been following since April 10.

    We bounced hard there, as the RSI chart indicated we might [see: 3rd Time a Charm] and completed a back test of the H&S pattern neckline [see: Back Test Complete] by actually closing on the neckline.

    This morning, we bagged the next target on our list, the 1.272 extension of the smaller Crab pattern (yellow) at 1343, which has me wondering…what’s next?

    Not that it always works this way (enjoy the streak!), but here’s the original list:

    • 1349.42 — .886 of the purple Butterfly
    • 1343.41 — 1.272 of the yellow Crab pattern
    • 1340.03 — horizontal support, prev. Point X
    • 1323.85 — 1.618 of yellow Crab
    • 1317.63 — 1.272 of purple Butterfly
    • 1289.14 — 1.618 of purple Butterfly (and 2.24 of Crab)

    The charts say there’s plenty more downside.  My top case remains 1289-1317.  Though we’re back to that RSI trend line (k-5) that provided yesterday’s bounce.  We can get to 1289 with a cross of that trend line or without. It’s a matter of “recharging” RSI with bounces such as we saw yesterday and this morning.

    At the end of the day, the “bottom” should exhibit positive divergence, and we’re nowhere near that yet.

    So, is it time to pile on more shorts?  If we’ve scored 5 waves down, we should see an a-b-c corrective wave.  As I posted last night, there’s a potential small H&S pattern developing in the right shoulder of the larger pattern.  Prices could loiter in the 1340-1370 area for a day or two and flesh out the small right shoulder before continuing down.  A 7-pt gain at the close would shake out lots of shorts.

    This would offer the added benefit of fully recharging RSI/MACD for the next push down — a very helpful development, should it occur.  I’ll be watching to see if RSI heads up into the intersection of that bold yellow trend line above with the bold yellow channel.

    Good luck to all.

     ********

    Now, we see that the euro zone is considering holding back the next installment of Greece’s bailout, some $5 billion or so. They have this crazy notion that the Greeks might renege on the austerity package/debt restructuring previously agreed to.  All together, now: “duh!”

    Whatever your opinion of why Greece has money problems, the bailout did very little to help the Greek people, who just expressed their heart-felt feelings about austerity in the voting booth. It mostly bailed out the bankers who made too many stupid loans to Greece (gee, where have we seen this before?)

     

     

  • So Far, So Good

    Over the past 5 weeks, our forecasts have been remarkably accurate.

    The Butterfly pattern identified back on Mar 29 [All the Pretty Butterflies] correctly called the 1422 interim top.  As anticipated on Apr 10, we got a bounce at 1357 (the .786 of the 1340-1422 rise) and began tracing out a head & shoulders pattern that fit with an analog of the Feb-May 2011 topping pattern [Analog Details].

    The analog been very accurate thus far, although the initial right shoulder bounce had us wondering whether the alternate path to 1462 was playing out.  Our RSI indicators kept us on the right path.  Instead, we got a complex H&S pattern, with a second test of the neckline and subsequent round trip to the shoulder line, accurately forecast in both time and price.

    Friday’s bounce at 1367 was within 2 points of our 1365 target [2d Time a Charm], with a nice little back test — as forecast — to the neckline, where we closed out the week.  The only reason I mention all the above is that, while this degree of accuracy is always desirable, it’s not typical and should not be expected.

    Regardless of how well your investments have performed the past five weeks, don’t forget that they are out to get you.  Even now, as it appears that the analog is playing out nicely, the financial establishment is working overtime to separate you from your money.  There will be more times, such as in January, when perfectly good harmonic and chart patterns don’t play out as they should.

    Always use stops!

    Now, with that out of my system, it looks like the results of the Greek and French election, on top of Friday’s dismal non-farm payroll numbers, is going to provide the push we need to get on with the downside.

    Remember, our target is 1288-1323, although 1288 has been fudged to 1295 simply because a dip below 1292 would be problematic for the bulls from a wave count perspective;  i.e., I think they’ll pull out all the stops to avoid it.

    Potential bounces along the way include:

    • 1349.42 — .886 of the purple Butterfly
    • 1343.41 — 1.272 of the yellow Crab pattern
    • 1340.03 — horizontal support, prev. Point X
    • 1323.85 — 1.618 of yellow Crab
    • 1317.63 — 1.272 of purple Butterfly
    • 1289.14 — 1.618 of purple Butterfly (and 2.24 of Crab)

    But, I divide the downside into three basic scenarios:

    (1)  stick save: Fed freaks over Europe, QEish leak limits downside to 1349.
    (2)  top case: normal Butterfly completion to 1.272 (1317) or 1.618 (1289.)
    (3)  panic sets in: crash and test bottom or large red rising wedge around 1200.

    I expected to be able to update all of the charts today, but my youngest daughter has been home with stomach flu while my wife and daughter #2 were at an all-day volleyball tournament.  Needless to say, it wasn’t as productive a day as I expected.  Look for updated charts Monday.

    *****************

    Over the next couple of days, I’ll finish converting the new website to a premium site.  Many thanks to those of you who have joined up.  I hope you’ve been able to act on my forecasts; if so, you’ve more than earned back your subscription costs in the first week.

    To anyone still thinking about it, the end is near.  The old site will still display articles of general interest and delayed market updates.  But, members of the new site will enjoy the first and best of what I can put out.  To join now, click here.

    Good luck to all.

  • Next Stop 1462? April 27, 2012

    Yesterday we explored the alternate path in detail, noting that one of the two RSI trend lines we’ve been watching had broken, and the second was coming into play.

    There is the possibility that the downward sloping red, dashed TL will catch it on the way up, but the yellow TL just broken was a major feat.  A close above the TL would imply a definite momentum shift.

    This morning, the second (red, dashed) trend line just gave way, lending more credence to the alternate path higher if — and this is key — we can manage to close above it.

    As can be seen on the chart above, there’s very little in the way of resistance between here and 1462.  We’re at the H&S shoulder line now, and it’s possible that the pattern will still play out.  But, as discussed in Bulls Fight Back, the pattern will start looking lopsided with much higher prices or passage of a few more days before it resolves.  It fails definitively at 1422.

    Harmonics give us some ideas as to the path forward and potential turning points.

    Here’s the bullish case — a Crab (the larger purple pattern) with the 1.618 At 1462.55.  There’s a good possibility that we’d see a reaction at 1414, which is the .886 of a Bat pattern and the 1.618 extension of the smaller Bat (in red, labeled in white) that’s nestled in the last two legs of the larger purple pattern.

    But the ultimate target is Point D at the 1.618 extension of 1462.  This is the apex of the rising wedge pattern (yellow) we’ve been in since 1074 and intersects with the SPX channel mid line (red, dashed.)

    Yet, there are plenty of reasons for the market to turn down and complete the H&S pattern, including the very faint possibility that reality sets in.  Here’s the bearish case — a Butterfly (in red) — that points to a low of 1305-1317.  BTW,  red Point C can go as high as Point A, but no higher, in order for the pattern to hold.

    That red, dashed channel mid line at which either alternative ends is a biggie.  Here’s the view of the past 20 years…

    And, the even more stunning view since 1935…

    There’s the possibility of a slight miscalculation when graphing anything over 77 years.  So, when I say it comes in at 1462, that’s an educated guess based on my best interpretation of what I can see.  But, it’s helpful to know that it corresponds with the Crab patttern 1.618 –and is darned close to the Fibonacci .886 retracement level of the 2007-2009 drop at 1472.

    I believe we’re destined to tag that line again before the next big downturn.  But, whether we get there directly from here or after a more extended wave 4 is not clear to me at the moment.  For now, the momentum is clearly with the bulls, especially when we can rally off of horrid economic numbers.

    Personally, I’m reigned in quite a bit right now — at least until the picture is a little clearer.

    **************

    The EURUSD has also defied logic, gaining slightly on the day to the point where it’s exceeding the channel that’s guided it for over a year.  But, the last month has traced out a Gartley that could see prices reverse around the .786 retracement of 1.3297.  Our high for the day so far is 1.3269.

    Stay tuned.

  • On the Verge: April 26, 2012

    UPDATE:  5:35 PM

    S&P cuts Spain two notches, from A to BBB+, based on contracting economy…cites declining disposable income, private sector deleveraging, front-loaded fiscal consolidation and an uncertain outlook for external demand in many of Spain’s key trading partners.

     

    UPDATE:  3:25 PM

    Here’s a close up of the alternative path, which looks stronger with every uptick.  I haven’t altered its course since first charting it a couple of weeks ago.  Remember, it remains only an alternative until the H&S pattern busts.

    As we originally discussed, the thick, red dashed line is our target.  It’s the center line of a channel that goes back to 1935.  Really.  The rising wedge apex intersects with it at around 1462, which is the 1.618 extension of the purple Crab pattern detialed below (Point X at 1422.38).

    FWIW, it’s also the 3.000 extension of the small Crab pattern (yellow) nestled in the B-C-D legs of the larger Crab.

    UPDATE:  3:15 PM

    Interesting that today’s ramp has come without any help from the euro zone.  EURUSD continues to stall at the channel line discussed in this morning’s update on the euro.

    ORIGINAL POST:  1:45 PM

    Yesterday we examined the fact that SPX had broken a 26-session channel and was in danger of following our alternative forecast higher — the purple dashed line marked “alt.” in the chart below.  Remember, that alternative calls for a strong move to 1462-1472 in short order, while the analog calls for a breakdown first.

    We took a close look at the RSI trend line that, broken back on the 5th when the rising wedge was broken, was being back tested big time.  I mentioned I’d be watching it like a hawk, as I felt it would hold the key to which way this confusion resolves.

    As of right now, that RSI trend line is being broken.  While it’s possible this is an intra-day head fake, I’m not so sure that I’m willing to bet cold, hard cash.  Note the highlighted circle on the RSI portion of the chart below.

    And, expanded here…

    There is the possibility that the downward sloping red, dashed TL will catch it on the way up, but the yellow TL just broken was a major feat.  A close above the TL would imply a definite momentum shift.

    From a bearish perspective, one small Bat pattern that indicated more downside busted when we moved above 1392.  The larger Butterfly (labeled in red) will need its Point C moved over to today’s high, but won’t bust until/unless we exceed 1422 (where C > A.)

    From a bullish perspective, the Bat/Crab pattern marked below in purple correlates very well with the smaller yellow Crab — which, until this morning, was just a Bat.  Remember, Bats terminate at the .886 retracement, and Crabs at the 1.618 extension (or more).

    The small yellow Crab’s 1.618 is 1413.74, while the larger purple Bat’s .886 is 1414.97.  When two targets are in such close proximity, it lends additional credence — all else being equal.    Technically, we could get a move to 1414ish and still have a valid H&S pattern, but as we discussed yesterday, it puts additional strain on the pattern — and the analog — playing out, unless we see a very quick reversal.

    As we approach 1400, the market should at least pause.  It’s the original H&S “idealized” shoulder line, the 1.272 of the small Crab pattern, and a nice round number.  But, unless we reverse in the next hour and see that RSI dip back below the TL, I’m increasingly positive about a move to at least 1414-1415 to fulfill the Crab and Bat.

    Remember, this is still a back test of the rising wedge.  But, I’ve been studying rising wedges a lot lately; and, as we discussed many times [see: In a Fix], it’s not uncommon for a back test to go on up and tag the original apex — faking out all who were playing the broken wedge.

    More later.

  • Analog Update: April 24, 2012

    The analog we’ve been watching since April 9 is playing out nicely so far.  We got the original bounce at 1357 as forecast, followed by a rise to the middle of our 1380-1400 target range.  The H&S pattern we expected did, in fact, set up and complete yesterday.

    Now, we’re back testing the little channel (solid yellow) formed by the right shoulder.  It was broken during yesterday’s plunge.

    As we discussed yesterday, if the wheels fall off the analog, it’s going to happen here — at the H&S neckline.  A hard bounce would likely send SPX up to tag the initial rising wedge apex at 1462-1472 (the purple dashed line.)  It can be viewed as a Crab pattern with the 1.618 at 1462 (in purple, points not marked.)

    But, I think we’re more likely to see the analog continue to work.  The key will be a failure of this morning’s rally/back test and a close below 1363.  Note that we’ve also established a channel to the downside (red, dashed) that coincides nicely with the harmonic picture.

    The pale blue Bat/Crab indicates a potential to 1335-1340, which would be a nice spot for a back test of the H&S pattern itself.  From there, the larger red Butterfly pattern takes over, with potential to 1317 (the 1.272) or 1289 (the 1.618.)  Though, a drop below last October’s 1292 would be a challenge.

    The key levels I’m monitoring today are 1378 — at which point the back test starts to intrude into the previous channel, and 1382 — at which point the larger red, dashed channel is jeopardized.

    Good luck to all.

  • VIX at a Crossroads: April 18, 2012

    Where there was once a falling wedge, there is now a channel.  The April 10 breakout that looked so promising completed a Bat pattern and promptly reversed nearly 61.8% of the move from the 13.66 bottom.  Is this the end of the ride, or are there bigger and better things in store for VIX?

    I have tentatively added another channel to the RSI to accommodate the latest spike.  It would likely guide the next leg down, if indeed that’s forthcoming — which I mostly doubt.

    Of course, every time we complete a Bat pattern with a Point D at the .886, we’re also establishing a potential Point B in a larger Crab pattern.  In this case, that would result in a completion Point D at the 1.618, which is 27.12.

    That’s an interesting price, because it equates with the 2.618 of the small Butterfly pattern potentially setting up on the hourly chart.

    Things get real interesting when you back out and look for competing or complimentary patterns.  On the 60-min chart, we can see that the move off the bottom conforms to a upward-sloping channel (in white) so far.  This channel will intersect with the downward sloping main channel (yellow) on Friday — which, of course, is OPEX.

    It’s only fitting that the point at which VIX must commit to one channel or the other arrives on OPEX.  The situation reflects the alternatives we’ve been discussing for SPX.  The analog we’ve been watching indicates a short-term top is at hand, and we should see a brief but scary sell-off in the next few days.  This would correlate with sideways action in VIX, followed by a breakout of the yellow channel to follow the white one — probably topping out at the 27.13 level at the bottom of SPX’s decline to around 1305-1317.

    The alternate SPX view is that we go on up and tag the rising wedge’s apex without the sell-off first.  There’s certainly enough important news in the pipeline over the next few days to bring either course to fruition.  Such a movement in stocks would mean the white channel breaks down and the yellow one holds — knocking VIX back to the 14.5 — 15.8 range.

    Of course, such a move would complete most of an inverse H&S pattern (in yellow) and set up the next upside break out.  Technically, we have enough of a right shoulder as it is, but a drop to around 16 would be ideal.

    In summary, my leading assumption is sideways until OPEX, then a breakout up to the 23-24 range to complete the IH&S that correlates with the SPX’s H&S move down.  We should then see a back test of the yellow neckline and subsequent push to the 27-30ish range to correlate with SPX’s move to 1307-1317.

    It would be a break of the yellow channel (which has a grand total of two anchor points on its upper bound) that would be similar to the Mar 16, 2011 breakout to 31.28 (see below.) But, such a move would bring it back the midline of the long-term channel that’s been such a magnet for breakouts over the past few years.

    That midline, by the way, is in the same neighborhood as the Inverse Head & Shoulders target of 28.20, which would be very doable if SPX were to plunge 70-80 points over the next week.

    But, keep the alternatives in mind.  The market is exceedingly hinky lately; and, as much as I like the analog, it’s certainly not guaranteed to play out.  As always, please use stops.

    Good luck to all.

  • Bottom Fishing

    EOD:  2:25 AM

    SPX overshot the Crab’s 1.618, whichever Point X we use.   The next major lines of harmonic support are are the red pattern’s 2.24 at 1342, correlating with the purple pattern’s 2.618 at 1341.

    Given the level of oversold on the day, here’s an alternative view.

    UPDATE:  11:55 AM

    The Crab Pattern I posted about earlier pulled a fast one on us.  It either busted, or I drew it wrong.

    Technically, it’s forbidden for Point C to exceed Point A — kind of like Wave 1/Wave 4 overlaps in Elliottworld.   But, it happens.   I’ve redrawn the Crab to begin with the March 23 1386 low instead of the March 29 1391 low — which means that the 1.618 extension is 1364.92 instead of 1372.51.

    Note the daily RSI tag on the same trend line (red, dashed) that stopped the Oct 4 and Nov 25 declines. The previous tags are highlighted in light blue.   This decline is picking up momentum, so the RSI TL and the Crab pattern might get mowed down.

    But, be cautious.   Like any trading system, once you start bending the rules in Harmonics, it opens up a can of worms.  Markets frequently overshoot logical targets, and it’s no cause to discard the methodology.

    I’m taking some profits off the table at these levels, and will let the rest ride essentially risk free.  Note that 1364 is the .707 of the 1340-1422 move.  If it doesn’t hold, the next support is at the .786, which would equal 1357.  An intra-day push to 1357 and close at 1364 would be interesting.

     

    ORIGINAL POST

    After yesterday’s close below the rising wedge, we can safely consider it officially broken.  Now, the question is whether SPX will freefall in an epic fail of the bull market, or find support at some interim level for another leg up.

    In the near term, we’re approaching a potential Crab Pattern turning point at 1372.51.  We might have reached it yesterday but for the little acceleration channel SPX has been in since 1422.  Today, the channel passes right through 1372, so we could get a good test.

    This isn’t a big pattern, so we might not see earth-shattering results, but it should be good for at least a nice bounce if not an outright reversal.

    I think an outright reversal might be in the cards, though.  The hourly RSI shows positive divergence with this morning’s leg down, and daily RSI shows a tag of an important internal trend line.  But, it’s the weekly RSI chart that, as a bear, really gives me pause.

    Expanding the RSI chart gives us a clear view of a trend line that might provide significant lift at these price levels (ignore the compressed upper chart.)

    I’ve also been watching VIX’s price action, constructing some probable channels months ago: the yellow channel guiding the downside, transitioning to the red channels for the subsequent rise.  Since then, I’ve barely adjusted them.

    Note how well they’ve called the turns.  At this point, they hint at a likely breather for VIX.  All things considered, I think we’re likely to see a backtest of the VIX falling wedge that will correspond with a return to the other side of the red channel.  It could happen any time, but might well occur coincident with the afore-mentioned bounce in SPX.

    All this begs the question, what kind of bounce will we see?  As we discussed the other day, this rising wedge is a reasonable facsimile of the 2010-2011 one [see: Analog Watch.]

    The most likely drawing of the current wedge puts the apex around 1460-1470 somewhere around May 7-11, meaning we reached only 88.6% of the potential in both time and price at the recent 1422 high.  [see: Was That It?] If we repeat the pattern, we’ll head back up to tag that apex — exactly as we did in May 2011 at 1370 (note the dashed white line that connects the March 2011 apex to the May 2011 top.)

    More importantly, however, we’d tag the upper bound of the huge rising wedge (red dashed) that dwarfs the rising wedge (yellow, solid) that just broke down.

    I’ve drawn its upper bound as the biggest, boldest red line I can muster on the above chart.  Why?

     

    Stay tuned.

  • Charts I’m Watching: March 22, 2012

    ORIGINAL POST: We’re finally seeing reactions on the harmonic pattern completions we’ve been watching for what seems like forever [see: Everything’s Coming Up Crabs.]RUT completed a Crab Pattern (in red) within the last leg of a Bat Pattern (purple) off the 2011 highs.  It never has cleared the TL off the May and July highs.  The May 2011 high was a double-top to 2007’s.

    COMP completed a tiny Crab within a little Butterfly pattern and tagged a key trend line off the 2007 highs.

    I call it a trend line because it’s exactly parallel to the line connecting the 2002 and 2009 lows.  A reversal here would make for four touches — i.e. a channel.  But, COMP could continue bucking its bearish divergence and go up to complete the larger Butterfly pattern (purple) at 3250-3295.

    DJIA still hasn’t made a new high since completing a Crab Pattern a stone’s throw away from a Butterfly Pattern (purple) completion at 13,338.64.  We’re still watching for a clean break of the rising wedge in the price chart and the trend line in the RSI chart.

     

    Though, it’s important to note that, at these prices, we came within 28 points of completing a Bat pattern (yellow) at the .886 (13,317) in the weekly chart.  That would make for a logical back test if/when the rising wedge finally breaks.  It might also be the 5th and final wave target if today’s move stays within the wedge itself — which is just as likely.

    Coming up….SPX.