Why Trading Has Been So Damn Hard

The futures are up over 30 points at present.  Why?  The headlines will point to China’s massive intervention, or this morning’s economic news, or maybe even speculation over the Fed’s upcoming action/inaction.

The reality is that the BoJ decided that things were getting out of hand, and they decided to bring USDJPY back to the magic salvation of the .618 Fib at 120.11.2015-09-07 USDJPY CU 60 0600Who in their right mind could have looked at Friday’s falling red channel and felt bullish about USDJPY’s prospects?  As we wrote on Friday:

Stay short over the weekend and risk a big pop higher over the 3-day weekend.  Go long and risk a 55-pt gap down.

When equities, bonds and oil are all taking their cues from the whims of the BoJ and their notion of when “enough is enough,” well… that isn’t really a market anymore, is it?

continued for membersFor all the excitement, ES is back to the IH&S neckline — no more.  SPX should play catch up, but bulls obviously need that neckline to be topped in order for the upside to develop.

2015-09-07 ES CU 60 0600SPX will be working on salvaging the rising white channel today, which means at least reaching the red midline for starters.  Unfortunately for bulls, even the 32 point gain in the futures won’t be enough to regain last week’s drop.  It’s going to need more, and quickly.  There’s no more room for downside if the analog is going to pay off.2015-09-07 SPX CU daily 0600UPDATE:  9:43 AM

Closing in on the red midline, also a TL from the Aug 28 highs.  I put it at around 1966.  ES and USDJPY are starting to rumble — maybe up for a push through.  But, I’d expect it to initially offer some resistance and an opportunity for day traders to take profits, and swing traders to face some tough decisions.2015-09-07 SPX 60 0643If it plays out as usual, it’ll not reach the objective on the initial push.  Keep a close eye on USDJPY and ES.

UPDATE:  9:53 AM

ES and USDJPY aren’t supporting any further push at this time.  It’s possible we’ll see a backtest of white channel line at 1947-1948 or even the SMA10 at 1943.48.  Traders might wish to take profits here and see what sort of downside develops.

But, it all depends on whether USDJPY can top 120.11 and ES can top that neckline.

2015-09-07 SPX 60 06532015-09-07 ES 60 0653 2015-09-07 USDJPY 60 0653UPDATE:  10:29 AM

ES backtested the SMA10, though the .382 at 1943.79 remains a possibility.  SPX is probably close enough to the white channel line to hazard a long position again.

2015-09-07 SPX 5 0729 2015-09-07 ES 60 0721Despite the nice pop this morning, remember that the bulls need to top the falling red channel midline (and, ES that neckline) in order for momentum to switch to bullish.  Until those goals are reached, these are nice day-trading gains in an environment of uncertain direction that is looking more bearish with each passing day.

UPDATE:  10:40 AM

This bounce isn’t taking.  USDJPY and ES are still slipping.  I’d be short again here and see if we can’t at least reach the channel line (1947ish) or SMA10 (1943.48, also the purple .500.)

2015-09-07 SPX 5 0740UPDATE:  10:46 AM

ES reached 1943.79, so good support unless it intend to tag the white channel bottom again (1940ish.) 2015-09-07 ES 60 0740 USDJPY is still slipping, possibly looking for SMA100 at 119.68 or white channel midline at 119.58?  2015-09-07 USDJPY 60 0751

SPX has reached the white channel line, still has a shot at the SMA10 unless ES and USDJPY suddenly rebound.  It’s worth a shot at a long position here, but just know that you might be reversing it momentarily.  Better to hold on and see where USDJPY bottoms.

2015-09-07 SPX 60 0743UPDATE:  11:25 AM

SPX just reached the top of the little red channel that fits this morning’s lows.  If it’s going to track lower to tag the SMA10 at 1943.48, this would be a good time.  Worth switching to short here at 1952.58, but I’d keep a close eye on USDJPY for confirmation.

2015-09-07 SPX 5 0825Not only that, but CL is on the rise.  For a discussion of why, check out the CL update just posted.2015-09-07 CL daily 0825UPDATE:  11:30 AM

USDJPY reached the SMA100, and possibly the white midline (perhaps if I were to draw it more bullishly.)  A strong rebound here would help ES/SPX break out.  If it sits here or even declines further, then SPX’s SMA10 is our next downside target.2015-09-07 USDJPY 60 0825UPDATE:  11:45 AM

USDJPY seems to be finding its feet.  It’s close to the white midline, and it has almost backtested the TL from the Aug 28 highs.  2015-09-07 USDJPY 60 0845Unless this is a headfake, SPX could be about to bottom.  1943.48 remains my top target — though the 5-min SMA200 doesn’t cross it for another couple of hours.  In other words, it could take a while.2015-09-07 SPX 5 0845UPDATE:  12:13 PM

SPX appears to be breaking out here on a USDJPY rally.  I’d switch back to long, though not sure how long it’ll last.  Initial target = 1957.69, a TL off Thursday’s highs.

2015-09-07 SPX 5 0913USDJPY in a moment…

UPDATE:  12:15 PM

USDJPY’s move…  There’s plenty more room in the falling purple channel for upside.  So, keep a close eye on it.  A push through the .786 line would be reason enough to dump the SPX short.2015-09-07 USDJPY 5 0916UPDATE:  12:30 PM

SPX just reached that TL off last Thursday’s highs as USDJPY reached the purple channel .786 line.  I’d short here at 1957.66 and look for a retracement to 1943.48, possibly around 1-1:30.  Obviously, tight stops are in order.  A push through this little TL signals the red channel midline and this morning’s original upside target at 1966ish.

2015-09-07 SPX 5 092302015-09-07 USDJPY 5 0930Note that ES has also reached channel resistance.2015-09-07 ES 60 0930UPDATE:  1:39 PM

SPX has behaved itself so far, and has run out of room to reach the SMA10 and still stay above the rising white TL.  Without another leg down soon, it will have to choose between the bullish rising white TL and the bearish one declining overhead — currently around 1956.25.

Clearly, a move through that TL should trigger a long position up to the red midline.2015-09-07 SPX 5 1038I’d ditch the short in a heartbeat, but USDJPY hasn’t gone anywhere since reaching the purple channel .786 line.  It appears as though it wants to dip down and tag the SMA200 or the rising white channel midline as originally discussed this morning.2015-09-07 USDJPY 5 1038Even if it pops higher, it still has the top of the purple channel to contend with.  In fact, tagging it could occur at the same time as SPX reaching the white TL.

UPDATE:  1:52 PM

USDJPY and SPX both just reached their interim targets.  Don’t know which way it’ll break, but the upside for SPX is 10 points up to 1965 and the downside is 13 points down to 1943.  I’m betting on a breakout and would go long on any move through 1956.

2015-09-08 USDJPY 5 1051 2015-09-08 SPX 5 1051UPDATE:  2:00 PM

It’s through.  Here’s where we find out whether USDJPY’s purple channel was legit.  An alternate exists, based on the highs instead of the lows.  It’s shown in white below.2015-09-08 USDJPY 5 1059FWIW, SPX still has the opportunity to tag the red midline up around 1965 and get back down to the SMA10 later in the day.  We’ll see if USDJPY is prepared to go the distance and get back to 120.11.

Also, remember that consumer credit data will be released at 3PM.   It often moves the market.  Expectations are for $18.0BB.  FWIW, 3PM is also about the time that SPX’s rising white channel midline should intersect the red channel midline.  Another breakout or breakdown opportunity…

UPDATE:  2:27 PM

SPX just officially tagged the purple .786 (came up just short this morning.)  Be careful, as this would be a good place for an unexpected reversal — truncated 5th or whatever.2015-09-08 SPX 5 1127 Keep an eye on USDJPY, which has also reached double channel midline resistance and is just shy of the .618 retrace from this morning’s highs (120.004.)  A failure to pop through would be dangerous for the bulls.2015-09-08 USDJPY 5 1127UPDATE:  2:43 PM

SPX has reached 1964.98.  I’d take profits here and short, but with a stop order in case the credit data prompts a spike higher.  Odds are we get a little sell-off, though.

2015-09-08 SPX 5 1143ES is at the neckline, trying to make up its mind.2015-09-08 ES 60 1139And, USDJPY was pushed back at the channel middle intersection.2015-09-08 USDJPY 5 1143UPDATE:  3:35 PM

SPX returned to 1966 on a USDJPY bounce, and then popped a little higher. I’d close the short position and sit out the rest of the session.  There is Fib resistance up at SPX 1967 and ES 1966…

2015-09-08 SPX 5 1231and USDJPY is likely to only backtest the white TL before falling further.2015-09-08 USDJPY 5 1231Not saying there isn’t more upside, or that the IH&S won’t pay off…just that I’d not be interested in chasing it or holding overnight after a 2.25% day.

 

 

Comments

2 responses to “Why Trading Has Been So Damn Hard”

  1. wick12@att.net Avatar
    wick12@att.net

    no worth considering this the end in a bear pennant flag pattern?

    1. pebblewriter Avatar

      It comes down to the neckline, whether or not ES can top it.