pebblewriter

Tag: H&S

  • Say What!?

    I wasn’t sure what to write about today until I got a great question from a reader, who hopefully won’t mind my reposting it here:

    Pebble, I enjoy your analysis, but are you really saying you bought at the low on Friday and you sold at the exact high yesterday?

    “After scalping a quick 36 points (going long Friday at 1292, selling at yesterday’s high of 1328.49) I got a little cocky and went long again at yesterday’s low of 1310 — even though it didn’t quite reach my 1309 target.  I got stopped out on the opening and am looking for a good re-entry point — probably just above 1300 from the looks of the 15-min chart.”

    DeMark 15 min is saying we will have a bottom shortly in the SPX.

    Lately I’ve been very, very fortunate in my forecasts and trading.  As readers know, I’ve been calling for a decline to 1288-1323 since April 9 [see: New Analog I’m Watching].  On May 6 [see: So Far, So Good], I refined it to 1295 and wrote:

    Remember, our target is 1288-1323, although 1288 has been fudged to 1295 simply because a dip below 1292 would be problematic for the bulls from a wave count perspective;  i.e., I think they’ll pull out all the stops to avoid it.

    In between, the market hit my upside target of 1415 on the nose, and just about every interim target on the way down.  We arrived at 1295 only two days later than my forecast from six weeks earlier (the purple line below.) So, trust me when I say I was fairly confident going into last Friday’s session.

    We were completing a Butterfly pattern at 1289.14, a Crab pattern at 1288.69 and were approaching a Head & Shoulders target of 1289.  And, a number of other indicators I watch were all screaming “here comes a bottom.”  I really, really expected a bounce.

    I had orders ready to go when we hit 1295. I drew a little trend line coming down the face of the RSI on the 5-min chart (purple dotted line, arrow A on chart below) and waited for it to be broken.  When it did, I started selling short positions (at around 1295.)  When RSI back-tested and showed positive divergence, SPX was around 1292; so I took a deep breath and started loading up longs (albeit with fairly tight stops, in case I was massively wrong!)

    Was I nervous?  Enormously.  In my nervousness, I devoted practically an entire post [see: Message in a Bottle] to the fact that I’d written myself a note in an April 12 post [see: Analog Details] to bolster my confidence in what I knew would be a very nervous moment a month later.  But, yes, after catching the very top, I caught the very bottom.

    As to 1328, that was much easier. As I wrote yesterday morning [see: On Track] my 1330 target was based on the previous H&S neckline.  But, I was also watching the Fib levels (red Fib lines above) and RSI activity — which was flashing overbought from the word go.

    The rise started slowing as we approached the .500 at 1328.82.  I felt we would probably build a Bat or Crab pattern to the upside, so a turn anywhere between .382 – .618 made sense.  Here we were, slowing at the .5000.  Hmmm…

    I went to the shorter term charts (5-60 minutes) to see what they were doing and noticed a trend line was in danger of being broken on the 5-minute RSI (note the red dotted line that runs roughly from A to B.)

    Within the next 15 minutes or so, that trend line was broken, and back-tested (the yellow arrow.)  That was all I needed to confirm a good entry point; so, I went short — with stops a little over 1330 just in case.

    And, it worked out pretty well — except that I got cocky and traded at the end of the day yesterday when SPX very nearly hit my 1309 target (it was my birthday, I was loopy on pineapple upside-down cake.)  Had I looked at the 5-min chart again, I would have waited.

    So, I got stopped out this morning at around 1305 and sat out until 1296-1298 (discussed at 10:40AM, occurred at 12:25PM) which so far is looking like the right move.  Note the back test of the channel — setting up more positive divergence.  I have stops in just below 1292 just in case, and still believe we’re in for lots of chop.

    With respect to DeMark, I know a lot of folks who follow him, and it seems we’re often of the same opinion.  But, I’ve never studied his methodology and don’t really keep track of his forecasts.  I do take some comfort — especially when taking a contrarian view — when smart people express concurring opinions.

    I sat watching my daughter play volleyball all weekend and ran into another dad who’s very smart and also in the investment management biz.  He asked how I’d done in the markets lately, and I started to tell him about catching the rise to 1422, the decline to 1357, the rise to 1415, and the decline to 1292.

    As I went on, I could see the word “bull****” forming on his lips.  I stopped talking and went back to watching volleyball.

    Good luck to all.

     

  • On Track

    Our forecast remains on track.  Since calling the 1422 top, we’re up a little over 20% on a cash basis (versus -6.5% for SPX) in a little over seven weeks.  We’re likely to pause around 1330, as this represents a key TL on RSI as well as the neckline of one of our recent H&S patterns.  The chart below shows several key price levels coming up.

    (more…)

  • Moment of Truth

    ORIGINAL POST:  4:30 AM

    The analog I posted on April 9 [see: New Analog I’m Watching] accurately forecast the move from 1422 to 1357, back up to 1415, then down to 1292.  As detailed in the last post [see: Why Bother], merely selling short SPX at the tops and buying in at the bottoms we forecast would have earned investors over 17% versus negative 9.4% for a buy and hold strategy.    That’s a differential of 26% that gets the new pebblewriter.com off to a great start.  Now, will it continue?

    (more…)

  • Somewhere Out There, Fibonacci’s Having a Good Laugh

    Some of you might remember this post from May 4.  I was struck by the Fibonacci relationships in both time and price between the last two major H&S patterns, and thought it confirmed my view that the H&S top was ready to play out.

    We all know what’s happened since then, of course.

    The reason I bring it up again is that horizontal purple trend line cutting across the chart from the October high (which helped drive prices higher for months.)  I don’t think it’s a coincidence that it’s at the same price as our H&S target — any more than it’s a coincidence that the latest pattern is:

    1.  1.618 the time of the previous pattern; and,
    2.   .618 of the target price range of the previous pattern.

    These Fibonacci relationships don’t tell us exactly what’s going to happen.  But, they’re practically screaming “pay attention! This could be important!”

    The obvious implication is that SPX will find its way down to 1289, the lowest of our targets initially presented over a month ago [see: Analog Details]  — though I continue to believe TPTB won’t allow a dip below 1292  (too many bearish implications.)

    I’ll post more after the close.

  • Analog Update: May 14, 2012

    Today’s action plays out well with the analog I first posted back on April 9 [see: Analog Watch] and charted on the 10th and 11th [Analog Details.]

    At the time, SPX had peaked at 1422, one point above a Butterfly target we identified on March 29 [see: All the Pretty Butterflies] and was on its way to our 1357 downside target (tagged later that day.)

    The subsequent completion of the right shoulder at the .886 Bat pattern target of 1415 [see: A Swing and a Hit] got the downside started on May 1, and it’s been all gravy since then — including the completion and back test (more…)

  • Running on Empty

    UPDATE:  EOD

    SPX went straight to our 1338 target and hung around pretty much all day — closing right on the H&S neckline.

    The analog I first posted on Mar 9 is still very much on track.  It called for the low 1300s by May 16 — which looks doable if we have another day or two like today.  Keep in mind, though, that while I had to pick a particular price target in order to chart the analog, I consider the downside to consist of a range from 1295-1323.

    UPDATE:  10:00

    We got the H&S completion we discussed earlier, seen below on the daily chart.  As expected we also got a bounce at the neckline.

     

    ORIGINAL POST:  9:20 AM

    With this morning’s continuing fallout from the latest JPM debacle, we should see the completion of the smaller H&S pattern we’ve been watching.  The neckline is around 1338, so look for a bounce there on the opening.

    As we discussed last Thursday [see: Still on Track], the latest H&S pattern targets 1275, but I believe it’ll be a challenge getting below 1292.  Remember, the overall targets I originally laid out on May 6 [see: So Far, So Good]:

    • 1349.42 — .886 of the purple Butterfly  [tagged May 8]
    • 1343.41 — 1.272 of the yellow Crab pattern [tagged May 9]
    • 1340.03 — horizontal support, prev. Point X [should tag this morning]
    • 1323.85 — 1.618 of yellow Crab
    • 1317.63 — 1.272 of purple Butterfly
    • 1289.14 — 1.618 of purple Butterfly (and 2.24 of Crab)

    Completion of the neckline mentioned above around 1338-1340 should also find horizontal support from the previous Point X (Mar 6) in the Butterfly pattern we’ve been watching since March [see: All the Pretty Butterflies.]

    But, my base case remains 1295-1317 for now.  It’s hard to calculate the damage that could be done by JPM’s screw-up.  As discussed last week [see: There is Nothing Wrong] JPM can easily withstand a $2-5 billion trading loss.  The danger is that much more damage lies beneath the surface — not difficult to imagine given the enormity of their $78 trillion derivatives portfolio.

    As I said back on April Fool’s Day [see: The Wipeout Ratio]:

    I fear this is the story of the year, folks.  And, it’s just now starting to get some press.  As we learned with AIG, if one segment of the financial markets suffers huge unanticipated losses, the entire house of cards can come crashing down.

    Such is the nature of today’s leveraged, re-hypothecated securities markets.  And, 99% of this stuff isn’t even quoted or openly traded, so who knows what skeletons are out there?  My gut tells me there’s plenty more where this came from.

    ***************

    And, for you Jackson Brown fans…

  • Still on Track

    ORIGINAL POST:

    In yesterday’s post [see: Two Targets Down], I theorized we would go up and trace out a right shoulder to complete a small H&S pattern in the right shoulder of the larger (completed) H&S.  So far, that’s exactly the way it’s playing out.

    As discussed, the perfectly-formed shoulder would take prices up around 1370 — a shoulder line parallel to the neckline, as well as the neckline of the larger H&S pattern.

    The 60-min RSI chart from May 8 forecast a back test of the solid yellow TL intersecting with the downward sloping yellow channel.  We got that, along with a clear rising wedge in the RSI to go with the triangle in SPX itself.

    From a timing standpoint, the ideal pattern will take 3-4 more days to play out — though there’s enough of a right shoulder now to consider it legit.  The target looks to be about 65 points below wherever we break back through the neckline, probably around 1275 (1340-65=1275).

    This is actually lower than the larger pattern’s target of around 1295.  I favor 1295 simply because I think the bulls will throw a fit if we threaten to take out the 1292 October highs.  Some of you more savvy Elliotticians know better than I what turmoil that would bring to the bullish case.

    More later.

     

  • Two Targets Down…

    Yesterday, we hit our initial downside target laid out over the weekend [see: So Far, So Good] when we nailed the Fibonacci .886 retracement of the Butterfly pattern (purple) we’ve been following since April 10.

    We bounced hard there, as the RSI chart indicated we might [see: 3rd Time a Charm] and completed a back test of the H&S pattern neckline [see: Back Test Complete] by actually closing on the neckline.

    This morning, we bagged the next target on our list, the 1.272 extension of the smaller Crab pattern (yellow) at 1343, which has me wondering…what’s next?

    Not that it always works this way (enjoy the streak!), but here’s the original list:

    • 1349.42 — .886 of the purple Butterfly
    • 1343.41 — 1.272 of the yellow Crab pattern
    • 1340.03 — horizontal support, prev. Point X
    • 1323.85 — 1.618 of yellow Crab
    • 1317.63 — 1.272 of purple Butterfly
    • 1289.14 — 1.618 of purple Butterfly (and 2.24 of Crab)

    The charts say there’s plenty more downside.  My top case remains 1289-1317.  Though we’re back to that RSI trend line (k-5) that provided yesterday’s bounce.  We can get to 1289 with a cross of that trend line or without. It’s a matter of “recharging” RSI with bounces such as we saw yesterday and this morning.

    At the end of the day, the “bottom” should exhibit positive divergence, and we’re nowhere near that yet.

    So, is it time to pile on more shorts?  If we’ve scored 5 waves down, we should see an a-b-c corrective wave.  As I posted last night, there’s a potential small H&S pattern developing in the right shoulder of the larger pattern.  Prices could loiter in the 1340-1370 area for a day or two and flesh out the small right shoulder before continuing down.  A 7-pt gain at the close would shake out lots of shorts.

    This would offer the added benefit of fully recharging RSI/MACD for the next push down — a very helpful development, should it occur.  I’ll be watching to see if RSI heads up into the intersection of that bold yellow trend line above with the bold yellow channel.

    Good luck to all.

     ********

    Now, we see that the euro zone is considering holding back the next installment of Greece’s bailout, some $5 billion or so. They have this crazy notion that the Greeks might renege on the austerity package/debt restructuring previously agreed to.  All together, now: “duh!”

    Whatever your opinion of why Greece has money problems, the bailout did very little to help the Greek people, who just expressed their heart-felt feelings about austerity in the voting booth. It mostly bailed out the bankers who made too many stupid loans to Greece (gee, where have we seen this before?)

     

     

  • Update on NDX: May 8, 2012

    UPDATE:  May 8, 2012

    The past two forecasts are still holding up well. I still believe we’re likely to test the large red rising wedge as detailed below.

    The completed H&S pattern targets 2446, which the large red RW crosses around May 16.  It also permits a wave down that doesn’t overlap with the October highs, which seems the most likely case.

    The RSI falling wedge we looked at last week is still progressing.

  • So Far, So Good

    Over the past 5 weeks, our forecasts have been remarkably accurate.

    The Butterfly pattern identified back on Mar 29 [All the Pretty Butterflies] correctly called the 1422 interim top.  As anticipated on Apr 10, we got a bounce at 1357 (the .786 of the 1340-1422 rise) and began tracing out a head & shoulders pattern that fit with an analog of the Feb-May 2011 topping pattern [Analog Details].

    The analog been very accurate thus far, although the initial right shoulder bounce had us wondering whether the alternate path to 1462 was playing out.  Our RSI indicators kept us on the right path.  Instead, we got a complex H&S pattern, with a second test of the neckline and subsequent round trip to the shoulder line, accurately forecast in both time and price.

    Friday’s bounce at 1367 was within 2 points of our 1365 target [2d Time a Charm], with a nice little back test — as forecast — to the neckline, where we closed out the week.  The only reason I mention all the above is that, while this degree of accuracy is always desirable, it’s not typical and should not be expected.

    Regardless of how well your investments have performed the past five weeks, don’t forget that they are out to get you.  Even now, as it appears that the analog is playing out nicely, the financial establishment is working overtime to separate you from your money.  There will be more times, such as in January, when perfectly good harmonic and chart patterns don’t play out as they should.

    Always use stops!

    Now, with that out of my system, it looks like the results of the Greek and French election, on top of Friday’s dismal non-farm payroll numbers, is going to provide the push we need to get on with the downside.

    Remember, our target is 1288-1323, although 1288 has been fudged to 1295 simply because a dip below 1292 would be problematic for the bulls from a wave count perspective;  i.e., I think they’ll pull out all the stops to avoid it.

    Potential bounces along the way include:

    • 1349.42 — .886 of the purple Butterfly
    • 1343.41 — 1.272 of the yellow Crab pattern
    • 1340.03 — horizontal support, prev. Point X
    • 1323.85 — 1.618 of yellow Crab
    • 1317.63 — 1.272 of purple Butterfly
    • 1289.14 — 1.618 of purple Butterfly (and 2.24 of Crab)

    But, I divide the downside into three basic scenarios:

    (1)  stick save: Fed freaks over Europe, QEish leak limits downside to 1349.
    (2)  top case: normal Butterfly completion to 1.272 (1317) or 1.618 (1289.)
    (3)  panic sets in: crash and test bottom or large red rising wedge around 1200.

    I expected to be able to update all of the charts today, but my youngest daughter has been home with stomach flu while my wife and daughter #2 were at an all-day volleyball tournament.  Needless to say, it wasn’t as productive a day as I expected.  Look for updated charts Monday.

    *****************

    Over the next couple of days, I’ll finish converting the new website to a premium site.  Many thanks to those of you who have joined up.  I hope you’ve been able to act on my forecasts; if so, you’ve more than earned back your subscription costs in the first week.

    To anyone still thinking about it, the end is near.  The old site will still display articles of general interest and delayed market updates.  But, members of the new site will enjoy the first and best of what I can put out.  To join now, click here.

    Good luck to all.