Say What!?

I wasn’t sure what to write about today until I got a great question from a reader, who hopefully won’t mind my reposting it here:

Pebble, I enjoy your analysis, but are you really saying you bought at the low on Friday and you sold at the exact high yesterday?

“After scalping a quick 36 points (going long Friday at 1292, selling at yesterday’s high of 1328.49) I got a little cocky and went long again at yesterday’s low of 1310 — even though it didn’t quite reach my 1309 target.  I got stopped out on the opening and am looking for a good re-entry point — probably just above 1300 from the looks of the 15-min chart.”

DeMark 15 min is saying we will have a bottom shortly in the SPX.

Lately I’ve been very, very fortunate in my forecasts and trading.  As readers know, I’ve been calling for a decline to 1288-1323 since April 9 [see: New Analog I’m Watching].  On May 6 [see: So Far, So Good], I refined it to 1295 and wrote:

Remember, our target is 1288-1323, although 1288 has been fudged to 1295 simply because a dip below 1292 would be problematic for the bulls from a wave count perspective;  i.e., I think they’ll pull out all the stops to avoid it.

In between, the market hit my upside target of 1415 on the nose, and just about every interim target on the way down.  We arrived at 1295 only two days later than my forecast from six weeks earlier (the purple line below.) So, trust me when I say I was fairly confident going into last Friday’s session.

We were completing a Butterfly pattern at 1289.14, a Crab pattern at 1288.69 and were approaching a Head & Shoulders target of 1289.  And, a number of other indicators I watch were all screaming “here comes a bottom.”  I really, really expected a bounce.

I had orders ready to go when we hit 1295. I drew a little trend line coming down the face of the RSI on the 5-min chart (purple dotted line, arrow A on chart below) and waited for it to be broken.  When it did, I started selling short positions (at around 1295.)  When RSI back-tested and showed positive divergence, SPX was around 1292; so I took a deep breath and started loading up longs (albeit with fairly tight stops, in case I was massively wrong!)

Was I nervous?  Enormously.  In my nervousness, I devoted practically an entire post [see: Message in a Bottle] to the fact that I’d written myself a note in an April 12 post [see: Analog Details] to bolster my confidence in what I knew would be a very nervous moment a month later.  But, yes, after catching the very top, I caught the very bottom.

As to 1328, that was much easier. As I wrote yesterday morning [see: On Track] my 1330 target was based on the previous H&S neckline.  But, I was also watching the Fib levels (red Fib lines above) and RSI activity — which was flashing overbought from the word go.

The rise started slowing as we approached the .500 at 1328.82.  I felt we would probably build a Bat or Crab pattern to the upside, so a turn anywhere between .382 – .618 made sense.  Here we were, slowing at the .5000.  Hmmm…

I went to the shorter term charts (5-60 minutes) to see what they were doing and noticed a trend line was in danger of being broken on the 5-minute RSI (note the red dotted line that runs roughly from A to B.)

Within the next 15 minutes or so, that trend line was broken, and back-tested (the yellow arrow.)  That was all I needed to confirm a good entry point; so, I went short — with stops a little over 1330 just in case.

And, it worked out pretty well — except that I got cocky and traded at the end of the day yesterday when SPX very nearly hit my 1309 target (it was my birthday, I was loopy on pineapple upside-down cake.)  Had I looked at the 5-min chart again, I would have waited.

So, I got stopped out this morning at around 1305 and sat out until 1296-1298 (discussed at 10:40AM, occurred at 12:25PM) which so far is looking like the right move.  Note the back test of the channel — setting up more positive divergence.  I have stops in just below 1292 just in case, and still believe we’re in for lots of chop.

With respect to DeMark, I know a lot of folks who follow him, and it seems we’re often of the same opinion.  But, I’ve never studied his methodology and don’t really keep track of his forecasts.  I do take some comfort — especially when taking a contrarian view — when smart people express concurring opinions.

I sat watching my daughter play volleyball all weekend and ran into another dad who’s very smart and also in the investment management biz.  He asked how I’d done in the markets lately, and I started to tell him about catching the rise to 1422, the decline to 1357, the rise to 1415, and the decline to 1292.

As I went on, I could see the word “bull****” forming on his lips.  I stopped talking and went back to watching volleyball.

Good luck to all.



Say What!? — 9 Comments

  1. I’m interested in speaking to you about your content. Please contact me at lee AT forexpros DOT com.

    Thank you,

    About Us 
    Founded in 2007, Forexpros is a definitive source
    for tools and information relating to the financial markets such as real-time
    quotes and streaming charts, up-to-date financial news, technical analysis,
    brokers directory & listings, an economic calendar, and tools &
    calculators. The site provides in-depth information on Currencies, Indices
    & Stocks, Futures and Options, Commodities, and Rates & Bonds. With a
    growing readership worldwide, Forexpros is a leading global financial portal
    that is constantly committed to launching innovative features and sections to
    ensure an optimal one-stop source for its readers.

  2. Oh Pebble, I was getting crazy worried as we BTFD today (and I bought early like you).  Just scalped off some profits and will let the rest ride for the time being, but not going to let it slide back to my bad entry at 1306.

    Good stuff as always.  Thanks for your guidance.  You da man.  Happy Birthday!

  3. I invite you when you are wondering what to write to just share with us what you are seeing so we can see it too. While I appreciate hearing how well you did I very much like hearing of what you are seeing in the present moments as they are unfolding.

    • Point taken.  I try to strike a balance between telling readers what I think is going to happen and educating them as to how to analyze these things (I want to provide fish, but more importantly to teach folks how to fish better.)

      Hopefully you saw my post yesterday about the 1338 top and expected decline to 1309; and, this morning’s post about being stopped out at 1305 and waiting for a new entry around 1300 (and post that I’m buying at 1298 at 10:55am).

      I strive to provide information on significant and longer-term movements, but like to include these intra-trend swings when I can.  I usually won’t have time to post every 10-20 point swing, but felt people would probably be wondering if the longer-term forecast has been jeopardized by the decline.

      • Thank you for your reply and for your thoughtfulness. 
        Yes, I did see your posts yesterday and today. I check for your updates many times every hour of the trading day.
        I lost money today trading around 1309 because I put too much importance on it. I believe the more you can share of what you are seeing happening will be very helpful for me because I am not yet seeing most of it until you point it out.
        Thank you again for listening and for your thoughtfulness. I believe you are wanting your website to be as good as you can make it. It is very good already in my opinion. I have been mostly enjoying it very much, just a little sadness at the moment for my mistakes.

        • Just remember, even the best calls can be undone by unforeseen events.  I always use stops, and recommend them to every investor.